Elbow Grease Cream vs Boy Butter: Lube Comparison
By Tantus Inc. Good Clean Fun | Published: 2026-10-24
Category: Comparisons
Compare Elbow Grease Cream Original and Boy Butter Original on ingredients, longevity, and cleanup to find your best long-lasting lube.
Quick answer
Choose Elbow Grease Cream for a thick, mineral-oil-based classic that lasts through long sessions, or Boy Butter Original for a coconut-oil-and-silicone blend that washes off easily with water.
Why the base ingredient matters
Elbow Grease Cream uses mineral oil and petrolatum, giving it a heavy, creamy texture that clings to skin and doesn't dry out during extended use. Boy Butter Original relies on coconut oil and organic silicone, which feels lighter and mimics the consistency of real butter.
Both are oil-based and safe for silicone toys, but the ingredient difference affects how they feel and how easily they wash off.
Longevity and cleanup trade-off
Elbow Grease Cream is famously long-lasting and friction-free, but it requires soap and water (or a dedicated cleaner) to fully remove from skin and fabric. Boy Butter Original is designed to wash off with water alone from both skin and fabric, making post-play cleanup simpler.
If you prioritize staying power over easy cleanup, Elbow Grease Cream wins. If you want a long-lasting lube that rinses away quickly, Boy Butter Original is the better fit.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Texture preference: Elbow Grease Cream is thick and creamy (mineral oil + petrolatum). Boy Butter Original is lighter and butter-like (coconut oil + silicone).
- Cleanup effort: Elbow Grease Cream needs soap or a cleaner. Boy Butter Original rinses off with water alone. If quick cleanup is a priority, Boy Butter Original saves time.
- Silicone toy safety: Both are oil-based and safe for silicone toys, unlike pure silicone lubes that can damage them. Either works for silicone toy play, but Boy Butter Original may feel less greasy.
Product facts
- Elbow Grease Cream Original Formula – 9 Oz.: Mineral oil-based cream that started it all in 1979; coats quickly for a long-lasting, friction-free experience. Its thick, creamy formula stays put during extended sessions, but it requires more effort to wash off completely.
Elbow Grease Cream Original Formula – 9 Oz. - Boy Butter Original 9 oz Squeeze: Oil-based lube made from coconut oil and organic silicone; homogenized like real butter and washes off with water alone. Combines silicone-like longevity with easy water cleanup, though it may feel less thick than a mineral-oil cream.
Boy Butter Original 9 oz Squeeze
Which one fits you?
Best for
- Elbow Grease Cream: marathon sessions where you want maximum staying power and don't mind extra cleanup.
- Boy Butter Original: everyday use where easy water cleanup and a lighter feel are more important.
Not ideal for
- Elbow Grease Cream: if you need a lube that rinses off with water alone.
- Boy Butter Original: if you prefer an ultra-thick, heavy cream that stays put without any slippage.
